Marcus Farrar has worked in a defence role within the criminal justice system since September 1997, qualifying as a solicitor during June 2002. Since 1998 Marcus has dealt purely with convicted prisoners advising and assisting on Prison Law matters.
Over the last 25 years, Marcus has become a specialist in parole reviews and judicial review cases.
After being employed at various solicitors in the West Yorkshire area Marcus became a self-employed solicitor in June 2005. He then established the Prison Law Department at Chivers Solicitors. Since then, the department has flourished.
Marcus took on the reins of Chivers Solicitors in June 2019.
The vast experience gained through these years made it possible for him to deal with a number of notable / reported cases. For example:
R v Fernandez (2002)
A successful appeal against conviction.
R (Spence) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (2003)
A case involving the timing of Parole Board reviews for life sentenced prisoners and the Secretary of State’s powers. The case confirmed that the Parole Board has no say in the timing of the next review.
R (Hare) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (2003)
A case involving a recall to prison and the reasons that justified the return to prison.
R v Cattaway (2003), R v Rutter (2003), R v Dyson (2003) and R v Mills (2004)
All four cases involved appeals of the minimum term (tariff). R v Mills (2004) being covered by The Times newspaper, December 2004.
R (Lindo) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (2004)
A case involving sentence calculation and days spent unlawfully at large.
Spence v UK (1190/04) ECHR (2004)
Mr M Farrar acted for Spence. The case involved an application to the ECHR regarding the timing between parole reviews and who is responsible for deciding on the length of time. The case established that the Secretary of State for Justice was responsible for making that decision, not the Parole Board.
R v Ford (2009)
Mr M Farrar acted in the case of R v Ford. The case involved an application to the Criminal Cases Review Commission in 1997. On the 12th December 2008 the CCRC referred the convictions to the Court of Appeal. Mr Ford was convicted of 12 burglaries, six robberies and an attempted robbery on 20 and 21 November 1996 at Bradford Crown Court. He was sentenced to a total of 25 years’ imprisonment. Mr Ford’s case was referred to the Court of Appeal Criminal Division by the CCRC, principally on the basis of fresh evidence found by that investigation concerning the treatment of an important prosecution witness. The Court of Appeal quashed the most serious convictions.
R v Shah (2009)
The case involved an investigation by the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) into the safety of Mr Shah’s conviction. The CCRC eventually referred the matter to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal quashed the conviction on the basis of gross prosecution misconduct. The main ground of appeal concerned the failure on the part of the prosecution to have the main witnesses at the original trial. The Court of Appeal found that the original court was misled into believing that steps had been taken to trace the main witnesses when no such steps had been taken. Therefore, Mr Shah did not have a fair trial. The case was widely reported in the media and legal publications.
R (Chester) v Secretary of State for Justice [2010] EWCA Civ 1439
A case involving a judicial review of the Government’s blanket ban on prisoners voting rights. The Court of Appeal found that it was for the Government to decide on legislation and when the legislation should be enacted. The Court also found that the judiciary should not interfere with the Government’s decision-making on forthcoming laws. The case was widely reported in the media and legal publications.
R (Faulkner) v Secretary of State for Justice and the Parole Board [2010] EWCA Civ 1434
The case involved the unjustified delay in the Parole Board considering the case at an oral hearing. That delay arguably breached the client’s rights. The Court of Appeal found that the client had spent 10 months longer in custody than he should have. The Court of Appeal found that there had been unjustified delay in the parole process. As a result, the Court of Appeal found that there had been a breach of Human Rights [Article 5(4) of the European Convention on Human Rights]. The case was widely reported in the media and legal publications.
R (on the application of Jones) v Parole Board [2010] EWHC 2462
The case involved a prisoner with an indeterminate sentence bringing a case against the Parole Board. The case involved factual errors and a claim that it was irrational for the decision maker to rely on evidence that was in complete contrast to all other evidence. The case was widely reported.
Broom v Secretary of State for Justice [2010] EWHC 2695 (Admin)
When transferred from Whitemoor prison to Wakefield Prison in May 2008, the client had historical photos of his children and nieces confiscated. He had been in possession of those photographs for 18 years. The individuals depicted were now adults. He challenged the decision not to return the photos to him by way of judicial review, claiming that it breached his right to respect for his private or family life. HHJ Behrens, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, concluded that there was no infringement of Article 8 of the ECHR in this case. The Judge described it as a “marginal decision”. The Court of Appeal granted permission to appeal. The Secretary of State for Justice then conceded the case.
R (on the application of Mullally & Smith) v Governor of HMP Lindholme [2010] EWHC 1356
The case involved the clients applying for re-categorisation from category C to category D. The clients had more than two years of their sentences left to serve. The governor had refused Category D on the ground of length of sentence alone. The Court had to consider whether the decisions were unlawful. The Administrative Court declined to make an order in respect of the client’s applications (mainly due to the fact a further review was then taking place). The court found that the governor’s decision was not unlawful though the decisions had been made hastily.
R (on the application of Shutt and Tetley v Secretary of State for Justice [2012] EWHC 851 (Admin)
Acted for both individuals. The case involved the application on the unlawful restriction of Enhanced Incentives and Earned Privileges (IEP) status for certain prisoners. The case concerned the consideration of both local and national policy relating to the IEP scheme. The local scheme at HMP Isle of Wight effectively denied enhanced status to certain convicted offenders who had been assessed as unready for a prison-based course. That appeared to conflict with the national policy. The High Court found the local policy to be unlawful.
R (on the application of Bright) v HMP Whitemoor [2012] CO/3179/2012 (Admin)
Acted for Mr Bright in his application against the unlawful restriction of condoms and lubricant to prisoners on the Dangerous and Severe Personality Disorder unit. The case concerned the consideration of local policy relating to gay prisoners. The local scheme at HMP Whitemoor effectively denied certain prisoners’ condoms and lubrication. The defendant did not oppose the application and permission was granted. The case was ultimately resolved in Mr Bright’s favour via a consent order.
Vinter & Others v UK (130/10) ECHR [2013]
Mr M Farrar acted for Moore. The case involved an application to the ECHR regarding the ‘whole life tariff’ in murder cases. The case established that the UK Courts can impose such a sentence.
Betteridge v UK (1497/10) ECHR [2013]
Acted for Betteridge in his application to the ECHR regarding the delay in his parole review. The ECHR examined whether Article 5(4) rights were engaged and, if there had been a breach, what damages should be paid.
Faulkner & another v Secretary of State for Justice and the Parole Board [2013] UKSC 23
The Supreme Court handed down judgement on 1st May 2013. The court decided that there had been unlawful / unreasonable delay in the parole review and that damages were applicable. The Supreme Court then decided on the level of damages.
Sturnham v The Parole Board and Secretary of State for Justice [2013] UKSC 47
The Supreme Court examined the proper test to be applied by the Parole Board when determining whether to direct the release of a person subject to a sentence of imprisonment for public protection (IPP).
Chester v Secretary of State for Justice [2013] UKSC 63
The Supreme Court handed down judgement on 16th October 2013. The case ended with the Supreme Court ruling that the present ban on prisoner voting was incompatible with the human rights legislation.
Faulkner v UK (68909/13) ECHR [2016]
The case involved an application to the ECHR regarding damages in cases where there was an unlawful delay between Parole Board reviews.
Gourlay v Parole Board [2020] UKSC 50
The leading case in relation to costs orders involving the Parole Board and other ‘court like’ bodies. The Parole Board decided not to direct Mr Gourlay’s release on licence and not to recommend that he be transferred to open conditions. We successfully challenged the latter part of that recommendation by way of judicial review. We then sought an order for costs against the Parole Board. Following the receipt of written submissions, the High Court declined to make this order. The Court of Appeal and, later, the Supreme Court upheld that decision.
Broom v Parole Board and the Secretary of State for Justice [2021] EWHC 3697 (Admin)
Marcus acted for Mr Broom in a successful challenge of a Parole Board decision refusing to recommend a transfer to Open conditions.
Murcott v Secretary of State for Justice [2025] EWHC 706 (Admin)
Acted for Mr Murcott in a successful challenge of a Cat A Review Team decision refusing to hold an oral hearing in a review of Category A status.
Marcus has also had articles published in the Inside Times and Converse newspapers.
